1971 – McCabe and Mrs. Miller

1971 – McCabe and Mrs. Miller

It’s an American Western, but it takes place in the mining mountains of Washington State rather than in the desert Southwest we’re used to. Directed by Robert Altman, it stars Warren Beatty as John McCabe, a gambler trying to make it big in a mining town by building a saloon, and Julie Christie as Constance Miller, a sex worker who goes into business with McCabe, managing both the brothel and the bathhouse. Their lives are upended when a big mining company wants to buy them out. I rented it on Apple TV for 3.99 Eur.

For my 23rd birthday, my boyfriend (now husband), my best friend, and I went to visit Gdańsk, staying in a hotel in the beach town of Sopot. I’m sure Gdańsk is beautiful and everything, but the weather wasn’t very good that long weekend in early November. It was a mixture of rain, hail, and snow, and the streets were pretty much empty.

After stomping through the city center for a bit, we ended up in a cozy café. I remember it was crowded, but we had amazing coffee and cake and ended up spending a few hours there. One reason is that the owners were playing Leonard Cohen on repeat – they must have gotten the newest album back then. It’s such a nice memory. I barely remember the architecture, but I do remember the café, how happy our dog was there, and how I told my friends about listening to Leonard Cohen as a kid. I

That’s exactly the feeling this movie evoked in me: the cold outside as a constant companion, while the people inside find happiness together. Nothing fancy, just a good stew that makes everybody happy, except the big corporate people who say it tastes rancid. And always in the background, there’s Leonard Cohen’s soundtrack. Especially Winter Lady gives one that melancholic, but loving feeling.

It’s a subversive Western: people run away from gunfights, the gambler hero actually loses at poker sometimes, and people say dumb stuff and talk over one another (an Altman signature) instead of delivering noble, perfectly thought-out lines. I ended up liking it much more than most Westerns.

A lot of that comes down to its distinctive setting. The town is like an additional protagonist, and you feel proud watching it grow, both in buildings and population. And yet there’s that constantly oppressive, howling wind and the ever-present mud. The rest comes down to the flawed human beings Altman captures, whom you love nonetheless. At the end, the whole town comes together to save a burning church. As you look into the faces of the people you’ve gotten to know over the course of the movie, you can’t help but feel a great love for them. McCabe and Mrs. Miller finds warmth and community in a cold, unforgiving place and makes you care deeply about the imperfect people who create them.

This wasn’t my first Robert Altman movie, but it’s been a while, and it was nice to recognize his style immediately. It’s a testament to his anti-establishment themes that you immediately side with the blundering gambler and the cunning Mrs. Miller over the big-shot executives, even when the executives offer McCabe a pretty good deal. I think I’ll watch a few more of Altman’s films now!

Leave a Reply